Search
A warmly lit gingerbread display in a traditional brick storefront window with evergreen garland on a quiet winter afternoon.

Fayetteville's Gingerbread Weekend Runs Through Court Street While the Fayette Theater Rebuilds

"This weekend is the chance to come in and look around and take photos of the nostalgia of the theater as it's been for years," Sharon Bibb, vice president of the Historic Fayette Theater's board, said in a story published on Yahoo News before the theater's final spring performances. "After this production, it will not look the same."

Those final shows were the musical "Wild, Wild, Wildest West," which ran March 27 to 29. The building is now closed for renovations, and the Historic Fayette Theater expects to welcome audiences back in the second half of 2027. That changes how Fayetteville's Christmas season works. Last year the theater's "Christmas in Comfort" ran three times during the Gingerbread Festival, on Friday night, Saturday afternoon and Saturday night. This year the Gingerbread Festival runs December 4 to 6, and its confirmed events fall on Saturday, December 5, all within a few blocks of the courthouse.

The Theater's Christmas Show Is Usually One of Its Biggest

The holiday production is a big part of the theater's year. Treasurer Wes Reid told a reporter covering the theater's gala fundraiser that the volunteer company usually stages three to four productions a year. A spring musical is usually the largest, a smaller show follows in September, and then comes the Christmas program, "another of its larger annual shows," which often casts children and sticks to traditional family themes. The company has staged community theater in this building since 1993.

The renovation should make that Christmas show easier to stage once the doors reopen. The project costs about $500,000. Nearly $375,000 is federal money, and the theater is covering a match of more than $125,000 itself. The work includes:

  • A heating and cooling system. Reid said the building has never had air conditioning, which has made summer programming hard.
  • Upgrades to the electrical system and plumbing, plus stage renovations and a new sound system.
  • New seats from the former Gauley Bridge High School auditorium, donated by the town of Gauley Bridge. Volunteers made several trips to unbolt the seats and haul them back. The new seats are larger, so capacity drops slightly, and they will be offset for better sightlines.
  • Theater leaders have named an expanded lobby and concession area, balcony improvements, and better audio and lighting as priorities.

The theater opened in 1938. Its first screening was the musical comedy "That Certain Age." Reid has said he hopes the exterior can one day get back "the full glory it had when it opened as a movie theater in the '30s." Bibb said the spring 2027 production will be "Princess Whatshername," a show she and Paul Neil directed at the theater in 2017. The theater's site points people to its Facebook page for construction updates and to a donation link for anyone who wants to help.

Saturday, December 5, Hour by Hour

Saturday runs in sequence from breakfast to the parade:

  1. 8 a.m. to noon: Breakfast with Santa at Cathedral Cafe, 134 S. Court St. The cafe calls this "one of our favorite Christmas traditions." Kids can sit on Santa's lap, or you can invite him over to your table. Talia Flour's Cookie Elf will be there selling boxes of homemade Christmas cookies, and the cafe serves breakfast and lunch all morning.
  2. 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.: Fayetteville Women's Club Christmas Craft Show at the Memorial Building. More than 50 vendors are inside, admission is free, and door prizes are raffled off through the day.
  3. Noon to 6 p.m.: Gingerbread Festival vendors on Court Street. This is the outdoor part of the day, and the festival page tells visitors to bundle up.
  4. 4 p.m.: Parade lineup at Fayetteville PK-8.
  5. 5 p.m.: The Gingerbread Festival Come Home For Christmas Parade. Groups can still register online or with the paper form linked on the festival page.

The craft show closes at 4 p.m., parade lineup starts at 4 p.m., and the Court Street vendors stay open until 6 p.m. That leaves an hour to shop outside before the parade and an hour after it. The festival also has a gingerbread decorating contest with youth and adult divisions, and registration is open through a form on the festival page.

Cathedral Cafe closes at 3 p.m. on regular weekends, so Saturday dinner means another stop. These hours were current as of September 2026, and winter schedules can shift, so call before you go:

Spot Address Saturday hours, as of September 2026
Pies and Pints 219 W. Maple Ave. 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Secret Sandwich Society 103 Keller Ave. 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. in summer, an hour earlier in winter
Southside Junction Tap House 101 S. Court St. 2 to 11 p.m.
Tequila Taco Bar 312 N. Court St. 11 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.
Patsy's at Hill Hall 135 High St. Brunch 8 a.m. to 2 p.m.; dinner 4 to 9 p.m.
Rosa's Speakeasy 201 W. Maple Ave. 5:30 to 9 p.m., reservation only, on Fridays and Saturdays November to May

This will be the first Gingerbread Festival for Patsy's. The restaurant opened August 28, 2026, in the lobby of the Hill Hall Hotel, in the old school buildings on High Street. Its executive chef is Jeffrey Toth, who founded Wood Iron Eatery in 2018, and the menu draws on Wendell family recipes such as molasses-glazed meatloaf and Clear Water trout. Rosa's takes reservations only, through OpenTable, so book ahead for parade night.

Sunday Moves Out to Fayette County Park

The holiday weekend doesn't end at the courthouse. On Sunday, December 6, Active Southern West Virginia holds its Ugly Sweater Fun Run/Walk from 4:30 to 7 p.m. at Fayette County Park, 1268 Fayette County Park Road. The route goes through the park's Winter Wonderland light display. It's an easy evening to plan, since it starts early enough for kids and gets you out to the lights during the festival weekend.

The Week Before the Festival, and the Weeks After

The season starts a week earlier, about nine miles north of town. On Small Business Saturday, November 28, Freefolk Brewery at 25385 Midland Trail in Hico holds a Craft Vendor Market from 2 to 6 p.m. It will have local craft and food vendors, Tony's International Cuisine, and Santa pet portraits that raise money for New River Animal Rescue. Freefolk closed its Court Street taproom and now pours only at the Hico brewhouse. The old taproom at 1690 Court St. is now La Bolilla, a pupuseria.

If you take holiday guests to see the gorge, Canyon Rim Visitor Center is open every day from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. all year. It closes on Thanksgiving, November 26, and on Christmas Day, December 25. On Thanksgiving weekend, plan the overlook for Friday.

Some local hours change once the weather turns. The Lost Paddle at ACE Adventure Resort switches to dinner on Fridays and Saturdays only after early October. Bridge Brew Works on the Nick Rahall Greenway keeps its taproom open through December, then closes for January and February. If you want a growler for the holidays, get it in December.

What the Dark Marquee Means for Next December

This is the first holiday season in years without a show at the theater. Fayetteville is giving up one December show so the building can get heating and cooling, a new sound system and the Gauley Bridge seats. The theater expects to reopen in the second half of 2027. If it does, next year's Christmas program could be one of the first shows in the renovated building. "We're going to really have to lean on our community in this process," Bibb said in the Yahoo News report. The theater is still looking for volunteers to help with the extra projects the grant doesn't cover, such as curtains and the upstairs bathrooms.

Until then, this year's festival happens on Saturday, December 5, from breakfast at Cathedral Cafe to the 5 p.m. parade on Court Street.

I'll be downtown on Gingerbread Saturday along with everyone else, and I love seeing Fayetteville fill up for the parade. If a December walk down Court Street has you wondering what your own home is worth now that town has new restaurants and a renovated theater on the way, Mendy Harvey can give you a clear answer. Start with a quick instant home valuation and we'll talk through it whenever it's convenient for you.

Work With Mendy

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.
Follow Mendy